FIXEDb104rel/platforms-stores3 min read
Epic Asks Supreme Court to Uphold Contempt Ruling Over Apple's 27% Web Fee
Epic's Supreme Court brief targets Apple's 27% external-purchase commission, arguing the combined cost with processing fees exceeds Apple's standard 30% cut and makes web stores unviable.

Patch notes
Epic filed a Supreme Court brief asking to preserve an April 2025 contempt ruling against Apple over external purchase restrictions
Apple charged a 27% commission on web purchases within seven days of an app link-out, on top of more than 3% in processing costs
Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers found Apple in willful violation of the injunction in April 2025 and barred off-app commissions
Fortnite returned to the U.S. App Store after nearly five years following the ruling
Supreme Court oral arguments on the contempt standard are scheduled for January 11, 2027
Epic Games has filed a brief with the U.S. Supreme Court asking it to preserve an April 2025 contempt ruling that barred Apple from collecting commissions on purchases completed outside the iOS App Store, GamesBeat reports.
The dispute centers on the 27% commission Apple introduced for transactions completed on the web within seven days of a user following a link from an iOS app. Epic CEO Tim Sweeney has publicly described the charge as a "junk fee." In its filing, Epic argues that Apple deliberately combined the commission with payment-processing costs and restrictive link designs to make alternative purchasing systems economically unviable for developers.
Why does the 27% rate matter to developers?
Apple normally collects as much as 30% through its in-app purchasing system. Under the external-purchase scheme Epic challenges, a developer using a third-party web payment provider would still owe Apple 27% while separately paying more than 3% in processing costs. The combined expense could exceed Apple's standard commission.
"As a result, developers actually would lose money by directing consumers to external payment systems," Epic's filing states.
The filing also cites an Apple executive who acknowledged that linked-out transactions would cost developers more than purchases processed through Apple at 30%. Epic claims Apple "reverse engineered" the rate to discourage developers from offering alternative payment options at all.
The commission came bundled with design mandates. Apple imposed requirements governing the placement and appearance of external links, restricted dynamic URLs (URLs generated with per-user parameters), dictated approved language, and forced a full-page warning screen before users could leave an app.
How did the case reach this point?
The litigation traces back to 2020, when Epic bypassed Apple's payment system inside Fortnite. Apple removed the game from the App Store, and Epic sued. Epic lost most of its antitrust claims, but courts ruled that Apple could not stop developers from informing customers about alternative purchasing methods.
Apple's response was to permit certain external links while introducing the 27% commission and the accompanying design restrictions. In April 2025, District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers found Apple in willful violation of the earlier injunction and prohibited it from collecting any commission on off-app purchases. The decision gave U.S. developers considerably more freedom to promote and operate their own web stores, and it cleared the way for Fortnite to return to the U.S. App Store after an absence of nearly five years.
An appeals court upheld the contempt finding but narrowed the remedy, ruling that banning every possible external-purchase fee was too broad. Apple may eventually be permitted to charge a limited amount covering costs genuinely necessary to support external links, but it cannot collect any commission until the district court approves an appropriate fee.
What question will the Supreme Court decide?
Apple argues it should not have been held in contempt because the original injunction never expressly prohibited commissions. Epic counters that this interpretation would let companies circumvent court orders by replacing prohibited practices with new restrictions that produce the same result.
The Supreme Court is therefore weighing the legal standard for contempt, not directly deciding whether 27% is a reasonable fee. That framing matters for developers: a ruling in Epic's favor would make it harder for platform holders to re-engineer workarounds around injunctions, while an Apple win would preserve latitude to attach fees to court-ordered openings.
Oral arguments are scheduled for January 11, 2027 — the next concrete signal of how much pricing freedom U.S. developers will retain over their own web stores.
via 80.lv (Source)
More from James Calloway
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around video game industry at Game Dev Wire.
223 articles