ADDEDb310rel/platforms-stores3 min read

Epic asks Supreme Court to uphold Apple’s contempt ruling

Epic Games says Apple defied a district-court injunction by charging 27% on open-web purchases and obscuring payment links. Apple says the order never barred such fees.

Epic Games tells Supreme Court that Apple was rightly held in contempt
Epic Games tells Supreme Court that Apple was rightly held in contemptJESHOOTS-com / pixabay

Patch notes

  • Epic Games asked the US Supreme Court to uphold the ruling that Apple was held in contempt over iPhone app payment rules.

  • Epic says Apple charged a 27% commission on open-web purchases after the district court’s injunction.

  • The US District Court barred Apple from blocking links to other payment systems or telling users those options existed.

  • The court of appeals upheld the contempt ruling; Apple says the Ninth Circuit recognised that the injunction did not mention commissions.

  • Apple says civil contempt requires no “fair ground of doubt,” a standard it traces to more than 140 years.

By Amara Osei

Epic Games, the maker of Fortnite, has asked the US Supreme Court to uphold the ruling that Apple was held in contempt over iPhone app payments, citing a 27% commission on open-web purchases and external links that became nearly impossible to find.

What did the district court order?

The US District Court barred Apple from stopping developers from linking users to other payment systems or telling users those options existed. Epic lost most of its antitrust claims in that case, but the district court later found Apple in contempt, and the court of appeals upheld that ruling.

Epic said in a post that it had filed the brief. Its claim is blunt:

“Rather than complying with the district court’s order, Apple started charging a 27% junk fee on purchases made on the open web and then made it nearly impossible for customers to link out to make those purchases. Contempt is for companies that knowingly violate court orders. That is exactly what Apple did.”

Why does Epic call this contempt?

Epic’s brief says the district court found Apple attempted a bad-faith cover-up, including presenting a “sham” report to justify the 27% fee. Epic also described the restrictions as a calculated scheme to evade the injunction, planned by top management.

The commercial claim sits underneath the legal one. Epic suggested the 27% commission was high enough for developers to lose money if users paid outside Apple’s system. For app businesses, that turns a payment-link dispute into a margin problem.

Epic’s case highlights two operational problems:

  • Visibility and usability: Epic says Apple made external payment links nearly impossible to find and painful to use.
  • Fee pressure: The 27% commission could make web payments unviable for developers, according to Epic’s argument.

How does Apple answer?

In its own brief, Apple argued that contempt ranks among the most potent powers a federal court can use. It said that, for over 140 years, a party could face civil contempt only if there was no “fair ground of doubt” that it had violated an order.

Apple’s case turns on the injunction’s wording. The text did not mention commissions, which the Ninth Circuit itself recognised, Apple said. The company also points to Epic’s concession that the district court did not explicitly ban a new fee on purchases made outside an app.

In its brief, Apple said it “strongly and respectfully disagrees” with the district court’s findings and had “devoted enormous resources to complying with the injunction.” Epic sees defiance; Apple sees a wording dispute.

What changes for studios and app businesses?

For studios, the dispute turns on what an allowed payment link is worth in practice. Epic’s answer: little if Apple makes the link difficult to find and attaches a 27% fee. Apple’s answer: the order addressed linking and disclosure, not commissions. On Apple’s reading, no deliberate breach has been established.

Until the Supreme Court rules, developers relying on external web payments face an unresolved question: can a platform charge a 27% commission while claiming to have complied with an order protecting those links? The next concrete signal will be the court’s treatment of fees and link usability when it decides whether Apple’s conduct amounted to contempt.

via supremecourt.gov (Original)

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around video game industry at Game Dev Wire.

254 articles