BALANCEb350rel/live-ops3 min read

Supercell CEO says Digital Fairness Act could hurt consumers

The EU's draft Digital Fairness Act would default off minors' in-game purchases. Supercell CEO Ilkka Paananen says clearer currency values and loot-box rules could hurt players.

Supercell CEO believes Digital Fairness Act will hurt consumers
Supercell CEO believes Digital Fairness Act will hurt consumersErik_Lucatero / pixabay

Patch notes

  • The EU draft would disable all in-game purchases by default for minors.

  • The proposal calls for clearer in-game currency values and disclosed loot-box odds.

  • Around 95% of Supercell's monthly players play for free.

  • Supercell launched Hay Day and Clash of Clans in 2012 and has since generated billions of dollars.

  • Pocket Gamer Connects London will discuss industry regulation on January 18 and 19.

The European Commission’s draft Digital Fairness Act would disable all in-game purchases by default for minors, require clearer in-game currency values and disclose loot-box odds.

Supercell CEO Ilkka Paananen argues the proposal will hurt consumers by making purchases harder and reducing the number of free games available. Last year, he warned that new EU policies risked killing Europe’s games sector. Supercell launched Hay Day and Clash of Clans in 2012 and has since generated billions of dollars. It is now one of Europe’s most successful gaming companies.

Around 95% of Supercell’s monthly players play for free. That is roughly 19 in every 20. Paananen says tighter purchase access could mean fewer free-to-play releases.

He says the Commission’s promised consumer protection will produce the opposite result.

What changes for studios and players?

The draft calls for in-game currencies to state their value more clearly, publishers to disclose loot-box odds, and users to be able to switch loot boxes off. Under the current draft, studios would need to alter currency displays, bundle presentation, odds disclosures and account controls across their free-to-play mobile catalogues in Europe.

The immediate operational burden sits in product and account management. Studios would need to revisit how currency packs and promotional offers are labeled, while product teams would need a loot-box disable control and age-specific purchase defaults. These are direct requirements in the current draft, rather than claims about a final implementation.

Paananen said: “The proposal’s idea of transparency is a euro value on in-game currency once bought at the time a player wants to use it. But players buy currency at different prices, through bundles and offers, so any euro figure is a guess. That is confusion, not clarity.”

The commercial effect remains Paananen’s forecast. He says harder purchase rules will mean fewer free games; no quantified impact for Supercell or Europe’s wider market accompanies that claim. For Supercell, the 95% free-player figure makes monetization design central to the policy debate.

Where do parents fit?

Paananen says the DFA moves purchase decisions for children from parents to the Commission. He also claims it treats everyone under 18 as a child, applying a stricter standard than the proposals for social media. The industry’s alternative keeps a parent in control while making child purchases off by default.

The European Games Developer Federation and Video Games Europe support Paananen’s position. They called the regulation as it stands “unworkable, unjustified and disproportionate” and asked for an urgent rethink. UK games trade body UKIE has also weighed in on potential industry harms, while other industry experts have expressed concerns about the proposal.

Paananen said: “We share the Commission's goal: safe play, especially for kids. The industry has already proposed tools that work. Purchases off by default for children, and only a parent can switch them on. Clear real-money prices. Refunds for unused currency. Let's build on those.

“I support Video Games Europe and EGDF's call for an urgent rethink.”

What happens next?

Industry regulation remains a scheduled topic at Pocket Gamer Connects London on January 18 and 19. The live issues are practical: whether minors’ purchases remain off by default, whether parents retain control, and how studios display currency values when bundles and offers produce different prices.

Supercell has not sized the draft’s commercial impact. The Commission’s response to the call for an urgent rethink is the decision worth watching, particularly for its currency disclosures, loot-box controls and treatment of under-18 players.

via pgconnects.com (Original)

Share this article:

More from Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett

Show full bio

News editor covering technology and product news in video game industry at Game Dev Wire.

250 articles