FIXEDb683rel/live-ops3 min read

EU Digital Fairness Act is 'game over', warn EGDF and Video Games Europe

EGDF and Video Games Europe call the EU's draft Digital Fairness Act 'unworkable and disproportionate', warning 8,700 studios face 6% turnover fines.

The DFA is "game over" for the European games industry
The DFA is "game over" for the European games industryQI_Jeffrey / pixabay

Patch notes

  • EGDF and Video Games Europe call the draft Digital Fairness Act 'unworkable, unjustified and disproportionate'.

  • The draft would disable paid in-game items and currencies for minors by default and require loot box odds disclosure.

  • Non-compliance fines could reach 6% of global turnover under the proposal.

  • Europe counts roughly 8,700 games companies, most of them small studios.

  • UKIE has also raised concerns; regulation is a keynote topic at Pocket Gamer Connects London, January 18-19.

The European Games Developer Federation and Video Games Europe have branded the European Commission's draft Digital Fairness Act "unworkable, unjustified and disproportionate", calling it "game over" for the region's games industry. Their joint statement lands after the EU published draft proposals that would disable paid in-game purchases for minors by default and impose new rules on virtual currencies and loot boxes.

The draft text requires publishers to state the real-money value of in-game currencies more clearly, disclose loot box odds, and give players the ability to switch loot boxes off entirely. Paid in-game items and currencies would be disabled by default for minors — a design change that would force reworks of monetization flows across free-to-play titles sold in the bloc.

What does the DFA change for studios?

Plenty, according to the trade bodies. Their core objection is legal certainty. "The proposed prohibition of pay-to-win and pay-to-progress mechanisms as written is fundamentally flawed, lacks clear definitions and would create huge confusion for players and developers alike," the statement reads. "In practice, the proposed prohibition could cover almost any purchase in a game."

That ambiguity carries real financial risk. The groups point to enforcement fines of up to 6% of global turnover under the draft, arguing that no developer could be sure whether their game breaks the DFA's rules — a compliance posture they deem unacceptable.

The joint statement does not hold back on consequences: "The draft would cripple the competitiveness of Europe's world-leading video games industry and leave millions of European players with fewer games and less choice."

Claims the Commission ignored industry proposals

Both organisations say the Commission disregarded their own alternative proposals. Those counter-proposals, as described in the statement, include:

  • Purchases and online communication switched off by default for children, with only a parent able to enable them.
  • Clear pricing displayed in real money.
  • Refunds for unused in-game currency.
  • Smaller currency top-ups, so players don't buy more than they need.

The groups argue the industry has already proven self- and co-regulation works. They cite the PEGI age rating system, which now also rates in-game purchases and paid random items, alongside existing parental control tools on console, PC and mobile that let parents block or limit spending. "By ignoring these efforts, the proposals risk fatally undermining industry-led innovation on safety not just in the games industry but in multiple other sectors," the statement adds.

A competitiveness argument with numbers

The trade bodies frame overregulation as a competitiveness problem, and they put a figure on it. Europe's 8,700 games companies — most of them small studios, they note — would "compete with one hand tied behind their backs against rivals outside the EU". The statement warns of "a devastating impact on a major European success story and on the millions of players who enjoy their games".

The industry pushback isn't confined to the two EU-level bodies. UK trade organisation UKIE has also weighed in on potential harms, and industry experts consulted by our sister coverage have voiced similar concerns about the proposals.

For developers and publishers, the practical stakes are concrete: default-off monetization for minors, mandatory odds disclosure, loot box opt-outs, and currency pricing transparency would each require engineering and live-ops changes if the draft survives in anything like its current form.

The debate continues in person soon. Industry regulation is a keynote topic at Pocket Gamer Connects London on January 18th and 19th, where the DFA's fate — and whether the Commission revises the definitions the industry is fighting over — will be squarely on the agenda.

via videogameseurope.eu (Original)

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Market editor covering technology and product news in video game industry at Game Dev Wire.

227 articles