BALANCEb400rel/live-ops3 min read

Game warns Digital Fairness Act could trigger 6% turnover fines

Game says the EU Digital Fairness Act could bring 6% turnover fines and rules for loot boxes, virtual currency and pay-to-win models, while Europe’s 8,700 games companies face competitiveness risks.

German Games Industry Association warns Digital Fairness Act could cause "double regulation and legal uncertainty"
German Games Industry Association warns Digital Fairness Act could cause "double regulation and legal uncertainty"JESHOOTS-com / pixabay

Patch notes

  • The European Commission presented its Digital Fairness Act draft yesterday following an earlier leak.

  • Potential DFA fines reach 6% of worldwide annual turnover.

  • The draft covers in-game purchases, virtual currency, loot boxes, pay-to-win mechanics and subscription-based games and services.

  • Game warns that USK and PEGI ratings would become meaningless if every game rated below 18 counts automatically as a service aimed at children.

  • A joint industry statement cites Europe’s 8,700 games companies, most of them small studios.

The German Games Industry Association (Game) warned that the proposed Digital Fairness Act (DFA) could expose games companies to fines of up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover. It also accused the draft of creating double regulation and legal uncertainty.

The European Commission presented its draft yesterday following an earlier leak. The proposal targets practices that exploit or harm consumers in digital markets, with games included among the sectors covered.

What does the draft cover?

The draft sets out rules for five commercial areas:

  • In-game purchases
  • Virtual currency
  • Loot boxes
  • Pay-to-win mechanics
  • Subscription-based games and services

For product and commercial teams, the immediate issue is mapping existing monetization systems to those categories, because the proposal covers both individual purchases and recurring subscriptions.

Game says blanket bans on in-game purchases would hit three areas hardest: loot boxes, pay-to-win mechanics and virtual currencies. The association argues that these mechanics underpin the free-to-play segment (F2P), which relies on optional purchases and generates a significant share of industry revenue.

The association also cites vague definitions such as pay-to-progress and an overall lack of clarity. Combined with a possible 6% worldwide-turnover penalty (a fine based on global annual revenue), those omissions leave studios uncertain about which purchase models the Commission will restrict.

“With the DFA, the Commission wants to regulate business models down to the last detail,” Game managing director Felix Falk said. “In doing so, it is putting at risk the competitiveness of European games companies, which are already struggling to hold their own globally.”

For studios, the immediate issue is whether optional purchases can continue operating under the draft’s proposed restrictions.

How would age ratings and parental control change?

Falk said the USK and PEGI age ratings would become meaningless if the draft were implemented because every game rated below 18 would automatically count as a service aimed at children. He argued that this would undo decades of successful rating work.

He also said the KIDS Act and DFA contradict each other. Under the KIDS Act, parents have a say over social media; the Commission would remove that decision from parents for games. Falk said that approach patronises parents and children alike.

The result would hollow out Germany’s successful co-regulation system (a framework involving the federal government and federal states), which those public bodies must now defend at EU level. Game believes the proposal would weaken two established mechanisms at once: game age ratings and parental involvement.

For studios and parents, the practical result would be displaced age ratings and different parental-control treatment for games and social media.

What does the wider industry opposition mean?

Game is not the only association opposed. The European Games Developer Federation and Video Games Europe also criticized the proposal, describing it as unworkable, unjustified and disproportionate.

“Overregulation is a competitiveness problem,” the joint statement said. “Europe’s 8,700 companies, most of them small studios, will compete with one hand tied behind their backs against rivals outside the EU.”

The groups said this would have a devastating impact on a major European success story and on the millions of players who enjoy those games.

Their objection is competitive rather than only legal: European companies would carry the draft’s restrictions while facing rivals outside the EU. In short, three European industry bodies now present the DFA as a competitiveness threat to the region’s 8,700 games companies.

The next signal worth watching is whether the Commission narrows the draft’s definitions and potential 6% penalty ceiling before the proposal advances.

via commission.europa.eu (Original)

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around video game industry at Game Dev Wire.

223 articles