POLICYb397rel/platforms-stores3 min read
Harada calls Xbox Series S 'extra work for a slightly weaker child'
Katsuhiro Harada says the Xbox Series S demands separate optimisation and clean code, while CD Projekt Red’s Pawel Sasko says the target tightens development work.

Patch notes
At SKY31 in Seoul, Harada said he wished hardware like the Xbox Series S had not been released.
The Series S requires a separate optimisation effort on top of the work needed for Series X.
Harada said US markets have more Series S users than Series X users, a claim the report did not independently quantify.
CD Projekt Red associate game director Pawel Sasko said the Series S forces studios to optimise their code cleanly.
Crimson Desert was cited as a difficult game to run on Series S.
Katsuhiro Harada, the longtime Tekken developer, said at Seoul’s SKY31 event that he wished hardware like the Xbox Series S had never been released, according to InvenGlobal.
His remarks came during a group discussion with industry heavyweights, with a senior Xbox official in attendance. “There’s something I really want to say while I have the floor,” Harada said. “Since a senior Xbox official is actually in attendance here today, I wish hardware like the Xbox Series S wouldn’t be released.”
That is a sharper complaint about development economics than console pricing. The Series S gives players a cheaper console by sacrificing some power. On the development side, Harada said its similarity to Series X creates a distinct problem: studios need another round of optimisation after making a release run smoothly on the higher-performance model.
“Low memory is an issue,” he said. “But the hardest part is that it’s a device so similar to Series X while having awkwardly lower performance.”
The key distinction is familiar hardware with uneven results, not a clearly different platform. Harada contrasted that with Switch 2. “When porting to Switch 2, developers can shift their mindset to ‘Switch 2 is a distinct device for Nintendo fans!’,” he said. “But with Xbox, after delivering your absolute best output, it feels like having to do extra work for a slightly weaker child.”
Why does Series S cost more development time?
The extra work is not limited to one setting. It includes a separate Series S optimisation pass, lower memory availability and the need to preserve clean code. Pawel Sasko, associate game director at CD Projekt Red, made that last point explicit: the Series S “forces us to optimize our code very cleanly.”
That makes the device resource-intensive when teams already have to support Series X. Harada’s analogy captures the frustration well. The platform remains recognizably Xbox, so players may expect near-identical output. The hardware asks studios to make another set of compromises to deliver a version that can run on Series S.
The commercial stakes shape Harada’s response. “In markets like the US, there are more Series S users than Series X users, so we can’t just cut corners,” he said. The report supplied no independent installation figures, so the comparison remains Harada’s market assertion rather than a documented statistic.
After launch, he said, Series S users often direct their complaints at developers rather than Microsoft. Their question, in his words: “Why is texture resolution lower only on Series S?” For the studio, that can mean scrutiny over a hardware limitation it did not choose, even though it must solve the technical problem.
What does this change for studios?
It requires teams to plan for a distinct Series S optimisation pass rather than assume that Series X support covers the lower-powered console. The source describes separate work on top of the effort needed for Series X. Low memory and lower performance complicate that pass. Clean code helps, as Sasko’s comment shows, but it does not remove the resource demand.
Players also need a clearer division of responsibility. Hardware trade-offs explain why texture resolution can fall on Series S. They do not erase the developer’s obligation to make the best version the hardware permits. Harada argued that people should understand those sacrifices before criticizing the result.
Crimson Desert illustrates the scale of the problem, according to the report. Getting that game running on Series S is no easy feat. Even disciplined code cannot remove every hardware constraint, leaving studios to do as much as the device allows.
The argument is not that the cheaper console lacks value. More hardware choices remain useful, and a less cynical middle ground is plausible. Harada also joked about the possibility of a “Helix S.” That is not a roadmap item. It is a concise expression of his complaint: a familiar Xbox machine can still force expensive, unwanted compromises.
The market signal to watch is whether studios begin disclosing separate Series S engineering costs or change how they allocate work across Xbox models. Harada’s criticism makes those choices harder to hide.
via gamesradar.com (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
News editor covering technology and product news in video game industry at Game Dev Wire.
250 articles