TUNEDb686rel/platforms-stores3 min read

EU Digital Fairness Act draft targets loot boxes and pay-to-win for minors

The EU's Digital Fairness Act, presented November 11th, would ban loot boxes and pay-to-win mechanics for minors, with parental approval required for in-game currencies.

Digital Fairness Act raises questions over future of mobile game monetisation
Digital Fairness Act raises questions over future of mobile game monetisationdaviscalalex / pixabay

Patch notes

  • The European Commission presented the Digital Fairness Act on November 11th, following a leaked draft.

  • The draft bans paid loot boxes and pay-to-win or pay-to-progress mechanics for minors, with no parental-control carve-out.

  • Parents must approve paid in-game currencies, and games must show their real-world value more clearly.

  • Dutch Games Association's Martine Spaans says the rules effectively block all free-to-play games from minors.

  • Analyst James Tamim notes the leaked text could still change considerably before adoption.

The European Commission's Digital Fairness Act, formally presented on November 11th, proposes banning paid loot boxes and pay-to-win mechanics for minors across the EU — a change that could effectively lock under-18s out of most free-to-play games. A leaked draft, published ahead of the official proposal, spells out the detail: prohibitions on pay-to-win and pay-to-progress mechanics for minors, mandatory parental approval for paid in-game currencies, clearer display of virtual currencies' real-world value, and broader provisions on "addictive design" that would let users disable engagement features such as daily login incentives and notifications.

What does the act change for studios?

The mechanics are familiar to anyone shipping a live-service mobile title. Artificial difficulty barriers fall inside the definition of banned pay-to-progress mechanisms. Without a clause allowing parental-control tools to re-enable them, the restrictions bite hard on free-to-play games aimed at younger audiences.

Martine Spaans, general manager at the Dutch Games Association, put the problem bluntly: "This effectively blocks all free-to-play games from minors, as artificial difficulty barriers are included in the definition of banned mechanisms." She also noted the absence of any parental-control carve-out for pay-to-win systems — the sort of omission that decides whether a studio redesigns its economy or geo-gates its game.

Oscar Clark, director at Arcanix.AI, warned the burden will not fall evenly. "Again, we are going to see regulations enforced by people who have insufficient understanding of game design and development," he told PocketGamer.biz. "Again, we will see the biggest impact on the smallest teams." Clark also flagged the risk of games being treated similarly to gambling, though he said he had yet to fully assess that danger.

He did not spare the industry. "Our failure to police bad actors and poorly implemented choices, as well as our failure as an industry to make our case, is on us. This is the price of those compounding failures." Short verdict: he's not wrong, and he knows it.

Harmonisation or 27 rulebooks in a trench coat?

The DFA's more contested feature is what it does to the existing patchwork of EU consumer protection law. EU digital policy analyst James Tamim sees an upside in the Commission replacing current directives with a regulation — a directly applicable instrument rather than 27 national transpositions. "That could mean greater legal certainty and easier compliance," he said, while acknowledging the new monetisation requirements will still sting.

Spaans is unconvinced the harmonisation is real. "We see the DFA leak still refers to allowing member states to adopt further national measures, so this would mean the DFA does not harmonise the rules across the EU. That is quite a disappointment." A single rulebook that permits local add-ons is, in compliance terms, not a single rulebook.

How does the Kids Act fit in?

The DFA also has to coexist with the proposed EU Kids Act, and the seams show. Both texts reference PEGI, default-off toggles and parental-control-based age assurance — yet neither clarifies PEGI's formal status as an EU standard, according to Spaans.

Trade body Video Games Europe has pushed on exactly this point. "While we welcome the recognition of the industry-led self and co-regulatory systems (PEGI and USK) — we call for these to become the de facto standard for games made available in Europe," it said in comments on the Kids Act. The body supports default-off settings for certain features and stronger parental say over children's access, but cautions against blanket age checks for all games and players.

What happens next?

Tamim's caution is the operative note: the leaked text is a draft, and "the final text could change considerably. But the implications for the gaming industry could be substantial." Watch the European Parliament and Council negotiations, where the parental-control carve-out Spaans wants either survives amendment or doesn't — that single clause could decide the shape of mobile monetisation for minors across 27 member states.

via videogameseurope.eu (Original)

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around video game industry at Game Dev Wire.

254 articles