ADDEDb425rel/platforms-stores3 min read

Choice names PlayStation in Shonky Awards over digital ownership

Choice has named Sony Interactive Entertainment a Shonky Award winner for 'asking us to pay to play, but not own,' arguing digital buyers hold revocable licences and will own 'nothing' once discs disappear.

PlayStation wins "hall of shame" award from consumer rights group
PlayStation wins "hall of shame" award from consumer rights groupSetupx3D / pixabay

Patch notes

  • Choice named Sony Interactive Entertainment a Shonky Award winner for 'asking us to pay to play, but not own'.

  • The Shonky Awards have run annually since 2006 as a consumer hall of shame.

  • Sony delisted several hundred digital films, revoking digital purchases with no refunds.

  • Choice also named the Xbox Mini Fridge in 2023 and charged $2.48 per minute for SimCity support in 2013.

  • Choice's verdict: 'You can't protect your licensed media based on the current EULA, and there won't be any alternatives once the discs go away. You'll own nothing.'

Choice, the Australian consumer rights organization, named Sony Interactive Entertainment one of its Shonky Award winners for what the group calls "the Shonky Award for asking us to pay to play, but not own" — an annual hall of shame running since 2006.

Choice's case rests on the difference between a purchase and a licence. "You don't actually own the movies and games that you buy as a digital download instead of a disc," the organization writes. "Instead, you're buying a license to access the content via Sony's various digital storefronts, such as the PlayStation Store."

In practice, digital PlayStation purchases operate as long-term rentals that Sony can revoke at any time — the same ownership grievance driving campaigns such as Stop Killing Games.

What happened when Sony delisted its digital film catalogue?

The award did not arrive in a vacuum. Sony delisted several hundred digital films from its storefronts, revoking digital purchases with no refunds issued, according to Choice. That gives the licence argument a concrete precedent: content paid for on a Sony account can vanish, and the buyer receives nothing back.

For platform holders, that asymmetry is the part that matters. A physical disc leaves the consumer with an object they can resell, lend or keep; a revoked licence leaves them with a receipt for a product they can no longer access.

Why does the end of physical media sharpen the dispute?

Sony still earns significant money from physical releases of its biggest games, but analysts argue the company is more interested in "control" of the market than in defending disc sales. None of those analysts are named in the write-up, so the reading should be treated as an argument rather than a measured forecast.

The mechanics support that interpretation. Without discs there is no used game market, which means Sony can take a cut of every transaction and set prices — alongside third-party publishers — without competition from secondhand sellers.

Publishers with physical editions keep a channel Sony does not control at the point of resale; under a licence-only model every sale routes through the platform's storefront and the platform's pricing. For studios, the practical question is whether digital margins compensate for the loss of that resale volume.

In plain terms: an all-digital PlayStation leaves Sony setting the terms and the price of every sale, with no second-hand market to push back.

How serious is the Shonky Award for Sony?

Choice has used the awards to single out gaming companies before. In 2023 it named the Xbox Mini Fridge for failing to cool anything while drawing more power than a full-sized fridge.

In 2013, when EA's always-online SimCity reboot launched to global server issues, Choice focused on Australian players, noting that the support line charged $2.48 per minute, "making people pay to complain."

The award cannot change a storefront policy, but it does place a documented consumer grievance on the record ahead of Sony's physical media wind-down.

What would resolve the complaint?

The unresolved lever is the PlayStation Store end-user licence agreement (EULA, the contract that governs every digital purchase). Choice's conclusion leaves no room for ambiguity: "You can't protect your licensed media based on the current EULA, and there won't be any alternatives once the discs go away. You'll own nothing."

For Sony, the commercial test is whether licence-based sales absorb the loss of disc revenue without driving more consumer resistance; for third-party publishers, it is whether pricing still matters once resale disappears.

Watch for any revision to Sony's PlayStation Store licence terms ahead of the physical media phase-out, and for the disc-versus-digital revenue disclosures that would show whether the control strategy is working.

via gamesradar.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around video game industry at Game Dev Wire.

223 articles