BALANCEb548rel/studios-leadership3 min read
Sony Cancels Fairgames, Its Live-Service Heist Shooter at Haven Studios
Sony has canceled Fairgames, Haven Studios' live-service heist shooter, after a large playtest showed weak retention. No layoffs are planned; the Montreal studio shifts to support work.

Patch notes
Sony canceled Fairgames, a live-service heist shooter announced in 2023 and delayed to 2026.
Executives Sean Decker and John Doyle cited mixed player feedback, weak retention and tough PVP shooter market conditions.
A recent playtest with thousands of players fell short of Sony's goals.
No layoffs are planned; Haven Studios shifts to supporting other PlayStation Studios teams.
April sources said the pre-alpha still could not 'find the fun.'
Sony has canceled Fairgames, the live-service PvPvE heist extraction shooter in development at Haven Studios, its Montreal subsidiary, and no layoffs will follow the decision, the company confirmed in a statement reported by Bloomberg's Jason Schreier.
The cancellation ends a project announced in 2023 that Sony had already delayed once. In 2025, the publisher pushed Haven's shooter from its original window to 2026. Now the game will not ship at all.
What did the playtest data show?
In an email to employees on Tuesday, Sony executives Sean Decker and John Doyle framed the decision around two factors: player feedback and retention from a recent large-scale test, and the state of the competitive market.
"While the test demonstrated strong operational excellence, live ops readiness and community engagement, player feedback and retention results were mixed and fell short of the goals we had set," Decker and Doyle wrote. "Combined with challenging market conditions in the PVP shooter genre, we have made the difficult decision to cease development on the game."
The test in question involved thousands of players. For a live-service title, where long-term monetization depends on sustained engagement rather than initial sales, weak retention in a pre-alpha playtest is a terminal signal rather than a tuning problem.
The session likely corresponds to a project codenamed Project Espresso, as IGN noted. That title, strongly reminiscent of Fairgames, ran private playtests in September. Few details emerged from those sessions, but they evidently did not produce results strong enough to alter the project's trajectory.
Concerns about the game predate the final test. In April, sources familiar with the latest playtest of the pre-alpha build said the project still could not "find the fun" — developer shorthand for a core gameplay loop that fails to engage players even before content and polish enter the equation.
The timeline, in brief:
- 2023: Sony announces Fairgames as a live-service title.
- 2025: Sony delays the shooter to 2026.
- April: Sources report the pre-alpha still cannot "find the fun."
- September: Private playtests run under the Project Espresso codename.
- Tuesday: Sony announces cancellation in an email to staff.
What happens to Haven Studios now?
Sony's statement on the studio's future is brief but operationally specific. "The studio will shift its focus to collaborating with other development teams across PlayStation Studios, while also exploring new creative opportunities," the company said.
In practice, that positions Haven as a support and co-development partner within the PlayStation Studios group rather than a lead studio shipping its own title. The company confirmed that no layoffs are planned, which distinguishes this cancellation from the wave of studio closures and headcount reductions that has followed other live-service failures across the industry.
Haven was founded in Montreal under industry veteran Jade Raymond and acquired by Sony before shipping a game, making Fairgames its first announced project. Its cancellation means the studio enters the support-and-collaboration phase without a released title to its name.
What does this signal for live-service strategy?
The decision marks another retreat in Sony's push into live-service gaming. Fairgames joins a growing list of cancelled or shuttered online initiatives from the publisher, and the executives' explicit reference to "challenging market conditions in the PVP shooter genre" acknowledges the commercial reality: the extraction and competitive shooter space is dominated by established titles, and late entrants face steep acquisition and retention costs.
The choice to kill a project after a large-scale test, rather than ship and iterate, suggests Sony is applying stricter go/no-go discipline to its live-service pipeline. Retention metrics in pre-alpha are now functioning as a hard gate.
The open question is what "new creative opportunities" Haven pursues, and whether Sony greenlights another original project at the Montreal studio or keeps it permanently in a support role.
via 80.lv (Source)
More from James Calloway
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around video game industry at Game Dev Wire.
223 articles