TUNEDb867rel/platforms-stores3 min read

House House's Big Walk weathered an AI review-bombing storm — and won

Big Walk's Steam reviews rebounded to 87% positive after House House disclosed LLM use on 'well under 0.1%' of its code, with Cliff Bleszinski telling critics to get over themselves.

Big Walk AI critics "need to get over themselves," says ex-Gears of War lead
Big Walk AI critics "need to get over themselves," says ex-Gears of War leadStartupStockPhotos / pixabay

Patch notes

  • House House says LLMs touched 'well under 0.1%' of Big Walk's overall code

  • Steam recent reviews recovered to 87% positive after review bombing

  • Cliff Bleszinski, ex-Gears of War lead designer, publicly defended the studio on Twitter

  • IGF jurors stated they won't vote for any production using AI under any circumstances

  • Big Walk shipped without Steam AI labelling, which Valve policy requires when AI is involved

Steam reviews for House House's Big Walk have recovered to a Very Positive rating, with recent reviews sitting at 87%, after an AI-disclosure controversy briefly dragged the co-op title into review-bombing territory. The recovery came fast, and it came with backup from one of the industry's more outspoken veterans.

Cliff Bleszinski, lead designer of the original Gears of War trilogy, went to bat for the developer on Twitter this week. "Wow, they're review-bombing Big Walk because it used some AI help to get out the door," he wrote. "People really need to get over themselves with this shit."

What did House House actually admit?

The studio confirmed earlier this week that large language models were used on small parts of the game — "well under 0.1%" of the overall code, according to House House's own accounting. The disclosure wasn't voluntary in the usual sense: it followed a statement from several Independent Games Festival jurors saying they would not vote for any production that used AI under any circumstances. House House told the IGF, then told everyone else.

One detail stung more than the usage itself. Big Walk shipped on Steam with no AI labelling, even though Valve's store policy requires disclosure when AI was involved. House House's explanation: "We have not made any disclosure on Steam as the platform does not request disclosure of code or chatbot usage." The studio added that it was posting the disclosure publicly because "it has become a matter of public interest."

That's a gap in Valve's enforcement worth noting. If Steam's questionnaire doesn't catch code-assisted LLM usage, studios operating in that grey zone face exposure exactly the way House House just did.

Is AI really ubiquitous among developers?

Bleszinski thinks the backlash misses the state of the industry. "Problem is the mob doesn't see it that way," he wrote in a follow-up reply. "SO many if not all devs are using it and no one can/wants to admit it now because of this crap."

Players, notably, split the difference. "AI sucks, but this got blown way out of proportion," one Steam reviewer wrote. Another drew a sharper line: "I'm all for hopping on the bandwagon when it comes to stopping generative AI from essentially making an entire game from scratch, but the love of god, AI being used as a tool to fix a bug that not even Unity themselves could fix might be one of the most reasonable uses for it I could imagine."

That second review cuts to the operational question studios actually face. Tool-assisted debugging versus generated content are very different propositions, and public opinion appears to distinguish between them even when review-bombers don't.

The bigger self-inflicted wound was timing. Had House House disclosed at launch rather than after IGF jurors forced the question, it likely avoids the dip entirely. That's now the working template for any small studio touching LLMs: say it early, say it precisely, and say how much.

Watch Valve's next move. If the Big Walk loophole — code and chatbot usage slipping past Steam's disclosure questionnaire — gets patched, every studio currently quiet about its toolchain will need an answer ready.

via gamesradar.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around video game industry at Game Dev Wire.

254 articles